Most pastors have a pretty good idea of what people think about their sermons. At least, we think we do. After the service, someone shakes our hand and tells us they enjoyed the message. Another person mentions how much they appreciated a particular point. Occasionally, someone tells us the sermon was exactly what they needed to hear. Those conversations are encouraging, and I certainly wouldn't want to discourage anyone from offering a kind word to their pastor.
But let's be honest. How often does someone approach you after worship and say, "Pastor, I really didn't understand your second point," or "I think you may have stretched that passage a little further than the text allows"? When was the last time someone told you that your sermon was unnecessarily complicated, that an illustration didn't connect, or that your tone sounded more frustrated than pastoral?
Most people aren't going to tell us those things. Some don't feel qualified to evaluate a sermon, while others simply don't want to hurt the pastor's feelings. Even those who recognize a problem may assume someone else will address it. As a result, pastors can preach week after week without receiving much meaningful feedback about their preaching.
This is one area where artificial intelligence can be a surprisingly useful tool. Before anyone gets nervous, I'm not suggesting that pastors should use AI to write their sermons, develop their outlines, or tell them what God wants their congregations to hear. The responsibility of studying Scripture, preparing the message, and faithfully preaching God's Word belongs to the pastor. No technology can replace that responsibility.
However, AI can serve as a constructive critic. It can examine a sermon we've already prepared, ask difficult questions, identify potential weaknesses, and help us recognize things we may have overlooked. Unlike the people shaking our hands after worship, it doesn't have to worry about hurting our feelings. Of course, AI can be wrong, and it sometimes offers criticism that isn't warranted. That's why the pastor must evaluate its feedback rather than simply accept everything it says.
I've found that the value of a tool often depends on the questions we ask it. With that in mind, here are six questions pastors can ask AI after preparing their sermons and before stepping into the pulpit on Sunday.
1. What Is the Main Idea of My Sermon, and Is It Communicated Clearly?
We may spend hours studying a passage, developing an outline, and preparing illustrations, but that doesn't guarantee our congregation will understand the central message. Sometimes we become so familiar with what we're trying to communicate that we assume everyone else can follow our thinking.
After completing your sermon, ask AI to identify its main idea based solely on what you've written. Don't tell it what you intended to communicate. Let it read the manuscript and explain what it believes the sermon is primarily about.
If its answer is substantially different from what you intended, that may indicate a problem with clarity or organization. Perhaps you've introduced too many competing ideas, spent too much time on a secondary issue, or failed to connect your points to the central message. You may know exactly where you're going, but that doesn't mean the congregation can follow you.
The purpose of this question is to determine whether the sermon you've prepared actually communicates the message you intended.
2. Where Might I Be Reading My Own Preferences or Assumptions into the Biblical Text?
Every pastor approaches Scripture with personal experiences, theological convictions, cultural influences, and preferences. Those things inevitably shape how we understand and communicate what we read. The danger comes when we begin allowing our assumptions to determine what a passage means rather than allowing the passage to shape our understanding.
This is where the issue of eisegesis becomes important. We want to draw the meaning out of Scripture through careful exegesis, rather than read our own ideas into the text. Even pastors who take biblical interpretation seriously can occasionally allow a favorite topic, personal frustration, or strongly held preference to influence how they handle a passage.
Ask AI to examine your sermon alongside the biblical passage and identify places where your conclusions may go beyond what the text actually supports. It may recognize assumptions you've made, applications that aren't clearly connected to the passage, or statements that deserve further examination.
This requires an important qualification. AI is not an authority on biblical interpretation. It can misunderstand Scripture, overlook context, or confidently offer an incorrect explanation. Its observations should send you back to the biblical text and your trusted study resources, not settle the matter for you.
Still, having something challenge our assumptions can be helpful, especially when we've become particularly attached to a point we want to make.
3. Where Am I Assuming My Listeners Already Agree with Me?
Pastors sometimes forget that the people listening to our sermons don't all approach Scripture with the same experiences, convictions, or level of spiritual maturity. A congregation may include lifelong believers, new Christians, people wrestling with their faith, and guests who have very little understanding of Christianity.
When we preach, it's easy to make statements that seem obvious to us because we've spent years studying and teaching the Bible. We may assume everyone understands why a particular biblical command matters or agrees with the conclusion we're drawing from a passage. Sometimes we move from a biblical statement to an application without adequately explaining the connection.
Ask AI to identify places where your sermon assumes agreement or understanding without providing sufficient explanation. It may recognize an argument that needs more development or a conclusion that could be difficult for someone unfamiliar with the subject to follow.
This doesn't mean we need to soften biblical truth to accommodate every possible objection. It means we should communicate that truth clearly enough for people to understand what Scripture teaches and why it matters. We shouldn't expect everyone to arrive at the same conclusion without helping them understand how we got there.
4. Where Is My Sermon Unclear or Too Dependent on Church Language?
Those of us who have spent much of our lives in church sometimes forget how much specialized language we use. Words like sanctification, justification, redemption, and propitiation communicate important biblical truths, but that doesn't mean everyone listening understands them.
The same problem can occur with phrases that aren't particularly theological. We tell people to walk in the Spirit, surrender everything to God, or live on mission without always explaining what those things look like in everyday life. We understand what we're trying to communicate, but someone unfamiliar with church language may struggle to follow us.
Ask AI to read your sermon from the perspective of someone with limited church experience and identify words, phrases, or explanations that may be confusing. You might be surprised by what it notices.
I'm certainly not suggesting that we remove important theological language from our preaching. In fact, preaching provides an excellent opportunity to teach people what those words mean. But if we're going to use them, we need to make sure we're explaining them.
There's no benefit in using a theological term correctly if half the congregation has no idea what we're talking about.
5. Where Does My Tone Sound More Like Lecturing Than Shepherding?
A sermon can be biblically accurate and still be communicated in a way that unnecessarily distances the pastor from the congregation. This is particularly important when preaching about difficult subjects, confronting sin, or addressing problems within the church.
Pastors are human. We experience frustration, disappointment, and occasionally anger. Sometimes those emotions can find their way into our preaching without our realizing it. A statement intended as a loving challenge may sound like a personal criticism. A necessary warning may come across as unnecessarily harsh because of how we've chosen to express it.
Ask AI to examine the tone of your sermon and identify places where your language may sound dismissive, condescending, frustrated, or unnecessarily confrontational. It can also help you recognize statements that may communicate something different from what you intended.
Of course, there are times when faithful preaching requires strong language. Scripture contains plenty of warnings, rebukes, and uncomfortable truths. The goal isn't to eliminate conviction or make every sermon sound gentle. It's to make sure our tone serves the biblical message rather than allowing our personal emotions to interfere with it.
We are called to shepherd the people God has entrusted to us, and that responsibility should influence how we communicate even the most difficult truths.
6. What Is the Most Likely Way Someone Could Misunderstand My Sermon?
One of the challenges of preaching is that we know what we mean when we say something. Unfortunately, our listeners don't have access to all the thoughts, explanations, and qualifications that went into preparing the sermon. They only hear what we actually communicate.
Sometimes a statement that makes perfect sense in our minds can be interpreted in a completely different way by someone listening. We may emphasize obedience in a way that unintentionally minimizes grace, or speak about God's sovereignty without adequately explaining human responsibility. An illustration may communicate something we never intended, or a particular phrase may leave listeners with an inaccurate understanding of our point.
Ask AI to identify the most likely ways someone could misunderstand your sermon. Encourage it to focus on reasonable misunderstandings rather than inventing unlikely objections.
This question can be particularly useful because it forces us to consider the message from the listener's perspective. We may discover that a sentence needs clarification, an illustration requires additional context, or a theological point deserves a more careful explanation.
We cannot prevent every misunderstanding, and we certainly shouldn't attempt to anticipate every possible objection. But when a potential misunderstanding is both reasonable and significant, it's worth addressing before Sunday morning.
Using AI Without Allowing It to Do Your Work
The key to using AI in sermon preparation is understanding its proper role. These questions are designed to evaluate a sermon you've already written. They aren't invitations for AI to develop your theology, create your illustrations, or determine how you should preach.
I would encourage pastors to complete their normal sermon preparation before using this approach. Study the passage, consult your resources, develop your outline, write your sermon, and spend time in prayer. Once you've done that work, provide AI with the biblical passage and your completed manuscript or detailed outline. Ask it to evaluate what you've prepared using these six questions.
You can even instruct it to avoid rewriting your sermon or suggesting replacement material. Tell it that you want honest, constructive criticism and specific references to portions of your manuscript that may need another look.
And remember that AI isn't always right. It may misunderstand your argument, overlook something you've already explained, or offer criticism based on faulty assumptions. You remain responsible for determining which observations are helpful and which should be disregarded.
There is also a practical consideration when using any online AI service. Avoid including confidential counseling details, private information about church members, or sensitive congregational situations in material you upload.
One More Set of Eyes Before Sunday
Most pastors want to preach the best sermon they can each week. We spend time studying, praying, writing, and revising because we understand the responsibility that comes with proclaiming God's Word. Yet even after all that preparation, we can miss things that might be obvious to someone approaching our sermon with fresh eyes.
Ideally, every pastor would have a trusted friend or fellow minister who could regularly provide thoughtful feedback. Those relationships are valuable and worth developing. But many pastors, especially those serving smaller churches, don't have someone available to review their sermons each week.
AI can provide another opportunity for evaluation. It won't replace the insight of a trusted colleague, the personal knowledge a pastor has of his congregation, or the work of the Holy Spirit. But it may help identify an unclear statement, expose an unsupported assumption, or recognize a weakness that deserves attention before the sermon is preached.
Here's my challenge for this week. Prepare your sermon just as you normally would. When you're finished, give AI your manuscript and ask these six questions. Resist the temptation to let it rewrite anything for you. Read its observations, return to your manuscript, and decide whether anything needs further attention.
You may discover that most of its criticism isn't particularly helpful. But if it identifies even one issue that allows you to handle Scripture more faithfully or communicate more clearly, the exercise will have been worth a few minutes of your time.
And unlike most people standing in the foyer after church, AI probably won't tell you it was a great sermon just because it wants to get to lunch.

